During this closed-door meeting, environmental organisations including International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW), World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA), Seal Alert, Seals of Nam, and South African Seal Saving Initiative (SA.SSI) presented the documented and proven facts demonstrating why the seal slaughter is illegal. One needn’t be a lawyer to comprehend that the seal slaughter in Namibia is illegal, but apparently not according to Gabriel Uahengo, a representative for the seal products industry, who instead of presenting factual information to justify the slaughter, turned the focus to Sea Shepherd for committing criminal activities and accusing foreign environmental organisations of challenging the sovereignty of Namibia. Mr. Uahengo failed to present a single fact to back up his accusations, so he couldn’t be taken seriously, and immediately following his presentation, the seal slaughter representative went back to his desk and proceeded to sleep through all of the other presentations.

However, Mr. Uahengo missed out on the best part of the meeting, the comedic-like display of misinformation and twisted scientific nonsense delivered by Titus Lilende, Deputy Director of the Ministry for Fisheries and Marine Resources. Mr. Lilende did not produce a single piece of peer-reviewed or documented scientific evidence regarding the ‘seal harvest,’ instead he explained that the assessment of seal numbers was based on some vague aerial picture and that the filmed evidence of illegal killing methods was all staged. The best bit of non-scientific nonsense was his claim that according to the government, the Cape fur seal is not protected or listed on the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) list II because the Cape fur seal is a ‘look-a-like seal’ and not endangered at all or protected at all. As usual, he stated that seals eat fish so therefore they have to kill the seals to protect their fisheries and that seals “don’t eat cucumber sandwiches.”

Sea Shepherd pledged to facilitate $30,000 towards job creation activities for the sealers if Namibia stops the seal slaughter, other nongovernmental organizations might be prepared to add to this figure when the Namibian government can provide the relevant economic data.

The ombudsman stated that he will make his findings publicly available before September 2012 which unfortunately means after next year’s seal slaughter, leaving Sea Shepherd with no other option than to return to Namibia next year to continue their mission where they left off.

The meeting room for the meeting with the OmbudsmanThe meeting room for the meeting with the Ombudsman Seal products representative asleep during the presentationsSeal products representative asleep during the presentations